Growing up, I always had a dog at my side—most notably, a gentle and clever collie cross who was more than just a pet, but a childhood companion.
That early bond stayed with me, and when I found myself in a position to get my own dog as an adult, I naturally gravitated toward the breed that had brought me so much joy and companionship growing up: the Border Collie.
As a woman in my twenties with an active lifestyle—running, hiking, and swimming are regular parts of my weekly routine—I knew I needed a dog who could not only keep up, but thrive alongside me. I also spend a lot of time paddleboarding, and with the hope of bringing a dog camping, I knew I needed a dog who would be adaptable to working hard and equally, resting.
Breed Research
When I started researching breeds, I took my time. I considered Springer Spaniels. This was a breed I had had little interaction with in my life. However, I adored their love of water and lively nature, but their background as gun dogs didn’t align with my experience or access to training environments suited for that purpose.
I was also intrigued by the Portuguese Water Dog, known for its swimming ability and curly coat, but ultimately, it felt less versatile in terms of sports training and mental challenges (still a dream dog for the future).
Some breeds were ruled out purely due to size: Labradors and Golden Retrievers and even Irish setters, while all excellent and wonderful companions, felt a bit too large for me. On the other end, smaller breeds like Cocker Spaniels or Terriers didn’t quite match the physical endurance I wanted in a companion. And then there’s the superficial side—I’ve always loved a dog with a bit of fluff, which ruled out short-coated breeds like Vizslas or Pointers.
Why a Border Collie Made Sense
Naturally, I gravitated back to my soul breed, a border collie. Border Collies stood out to me as a breed that ticked nearly every box:
● Energy Levels: These dogs are built for stamina and thrive with regular, challenging exercise. Whilst Broc is still a puppy, I know he will keep up with me in future when I’m heading out for a 10k run, a trail hike, or a long walk on the beach. My Collie, Broc, is always ready and eager to go.
● Trainability: Border Collies are notoriously intelligent. I had always dreamed of doing agility and obedience work, and the breed’s ability to learn quickly and respond to cues makes them a joy to train. Broc has shown an instinct for agility and obedience training already at only 8 months.
● Size and Coat: I wanted a medium-sized dog—easy to transport, but still sturdy enough for outdoor activities. That iconic Collie coat is beautiful and expressive, and though it does take some upkeep, brushing Broc is not a huge chore, and water runs off his double coat easily.
● Versatility: From herding to agility, from scent work to therapy work, Border Collies are capable of excelling in many areas. I liked knowing that I’d never run out of ways to mentally and physically challenge my dog.
The Border Collie Realities:
Border Collies are incredible, but they’re not the right dog for everyone. I think it’s important to be honest about the pros and cons, especially for first-time owners.
Pros:
● Exceptional intelligence and trainability – if you have the time and patience. ● Great companions for active, outdoorsy lifestyles.
● Eager to learn and quick to respond to commands.
● Can excel in dog sports and competitions.
● Loyal, sensitive, and intuitive.
Cons:
● High Energy: These dogs need more than a daily walk, which often will not stimulate their brain. I use a mix of sniffy walks/ training walks/ long-line and off-leash walks on a weekly basis alongside training and numerous herding games. Without proper physical and mental stimulation, they can become bored and destructive.
● Mental Stimulation is Essential: A tired Collie is a happy Collie—but not just physically. They need puzzles, training, scent work, or problem-solving games to stay fulfilled.
● Sensitivity: While this is also a pro, their sensitivity means they can be overwhelmed by chaotic environments or harsh training methods – Collies can sometimes become very fearful and reactive which can result in training issues.
● Herding Instincts: Without proper redirection, some Collies may nip at heels or try to herd children or other pets.
Broc: My Everyday Adventure Buddy
Broc, my blue merle Border Collie, has brought more adventure and purpose to my life than I could have imagined.
From muddy mountain trails to quiet moments by the sea, he’s not just my dog—he’s my partner.
Every day is a mix of play, work, and training. We’ve started foundation agility and obedience training, and I’m hopeful we’ll compete one day. He thrives on structure and stimulation, and it pushes me to be more consistent, more patient, and more present.
Choosing a Border Collie was one of the best decisions I’ve made—but it wasn’t a spontaneous one. It took careful thought, lifestyle planning, and honesty about what I could offer a dog.
If you’re active, consistent, and ready to embrace the unique challenges and joys of a working breed, a Border Collie might just be the dog for you.
You can follow mine and Broc’s adventures on Instagram.